Palace Hotel and Sarah Althea Hill
A dispute over one sheet of paper ended with a former chief justice shot dead beside a Supreme Court justice.

Listen to this place’s story in Peplos.
How the story begins
Five hundred dollars a month, Senator William Sharon later testified, was his standard proposal to all of his mistresses. Sarah Althea Hill refused it, so he doubled it. Sharon owned the Palace and the Grand, joined by a bridge over New Montgomery Street. She had rooms in the Grand. After about a year he ordered her out. She refused. He had the carpet outside her rooms taken up, and then her front door taken off.
The rest is in the app. Peplos plays the full story when you reach the place. You can also listen ahead of time.
Visiting
2 New Montgomery Street, at Market. The present hotel dates from 1909; the Grand is gone. A working hotel with a restaurant in its Garden Court. City Guides volunteers run free walking tours here; check the schedule before you go.
Sources
- Federal Judicial Center: In re Terry
- Nancy Leek, The Scandalous Saga of Senator Sharon and Sarah Althea Hill (Goldfields Books)
- Wikipedia: Sarah Althea Hill
- Wikipedia: David S. Terry
- Wikipedia: Palace Hotel, San Francisco
- Sharon/Hill Divorce and Terry/Field Affair (Great American Trials)
- In re Neagle, 135 U.S. 1 (Cornell Legal Information Institute)
- San Francisco News Letter, 1880 (Museum of the City of San Francisco)
This text was written by AI from open sources. Found a mistake? Write to us. Support